Emergence is the missing piece
If you don't understand emergence, you don't understand reality.
Emergence refers to properties of systems that appear at the whole level but cannot be explained by it's reduced components. It is the key to complexity, consciousness, and the cosmos.
It is a highly contested topic, as it not only challenges specific scientific paradigms- it questions the foundation of reductionism itself.
For nearly 100 years, humanity has dismissed nearly everything that cannot be explained by reduced science, and in doing so, may have dismissed the most important components of reality~
Join the Dogma Balls Discord
Curious about emergence? Wanna discuss some theories? Wanna tell me I'm dumb?
Join the Dogma Balls discord and share your own experiences and insights.
Examples of Emergence
Swarm Behavior
Life from Earth's Chemical Soup
Swarm Behavior
The coordinated movement of birds in a flock or fish in a school emerges from simple individual behaviors without any leader.
Each bird or fish follows basic rules: stay close but not too close, align direction with neighbors, and avoid obstacles.
These individual guidelines allow a collective intelligence to emerge, gracefully guiding swarms of birds without there being any one leader.
Consciousness
Life from Earth's Chemical Soup
Swarm Behavior
Consciousness is deeply personal and yet profoundly mysterious.
Billions of neurons firing in your brain, each following basic electrical and chemical rules, somehow create the human experience.
Consciousness is often cited as the pinnacle of emergence, as it exemplifies something entirely different from, and irreducible to, its components.
Life from Earth's Chemical Soup
Life from Earth's Chemical Soup
Life from Earth's Chemical Soup
Life itself is a quintessential emergent phenomenon.
Simple molecules like amino acids and nucleotides, interacting under the right conditions, organize into self-replicating structures that lead to cells and the entirety of life.
This demonstrates how complexity arises not from external design but from self-organization and interaction.
...OR IS IT? The Weak vs strong emergence debate
Weak Emergence
- Definition: Phenomena that appear emergent but are ultimately explainable through the interactions of the system's components.
- Key Idea: While the behavior may be surprising or complex, it is computationally reducible, meaning we can simulate or predict the emergent properties by understanding the rules of the parts.
Examples:
- Conway’s Game of Life: Complex patterns emerge from simple rules but can be fully explained by those rules.
- Traffic flow: Complex patterns like traffic jams emerge, but they are predictable based on individual driver behaviors and interactions.
- Reductionist View: Weak emergence is consistent with reductionism because it doesn’t challenge the idea that the whole can ultimately be reduced to the sum of its parts. Reductionists argue that weak emergence is a matter of computational complexity, not a fundamental shift in understanding.
Strong Emergence
- Definition: Phenomena that are truly novel and cannot be reduced to, or fully explained by, the properties and interactions of their parts.
- Key Idea: Strong emergence suggests that new laws or principles operate at the level of the whole that are irreducible to the system's components.
Examples (Debated):
- Consciousness: Many argue that subjective experience cannot be reduced to neural activity alone.
- Life: Some claim that life’s self-organizing, adaptive behaviors transcend mere chemistry.
- Reductionist Critique: Strong emergence challenges reductionism by suggesting that the whole isn’t just greater than the sum of its parts—it operates by entirely different principles. Reductionists often reject strong emergence, arguing that it implies untestable or "magical" explanations. But could this effectively be divine design?